PostgreSQL中的八级锁__锁是实现数据库并发控制必不可少的功能，PostgreSQL数据库通过其特有的多版本属性实现了MVCC，实现了读不阻塞写，写不阻塞读。PostgreSQL中表锁有八个级别，不同的锁对应了不同的排他级别。值得注意的是同一时刻两个事务不能再同一个表上获取相互冲突的锁，但是一个事务是永远不会与自己冲突的，一个事务里连续获取两个有冲突的锁类型是没有问题的。_

PG中文社区 /

mdi-home

首页

社区新闻

中文文档

加入ACE

mdi-home

首页

mdi-chat-processing

社区新闻

mdi-book-open-variant

中文文档

mdi-account-multiple-check

加入ACE

mdi-file-multiple-outline

相关资料

mdi-blank

mdi-exit-to-app

退出账号

PostgreSQL中的八级锁

原作者：　　创作时间：2020-07-08 14:42:52+08　　

wangliyun 发布于2020-07-09 08:00:00　　

评论: 18501　　

顶: 23921　

踩: 22622　

### **本文转载自公众号《数据库架构之美》**
#### 锁是实现数据库并发控制必不可少的功能，PostgreSQL数据库通过其特有的多版本属性实现了MVCC，实现了读不阻塞写，写不阻塞读。PostgreSQL中表锁有八个级别，不同的锁对应了不同的排他级别。值得注意的是同一时刻两个事务不能再同一个表上获取相互冲突的锁，但是一个事务是永远不会与自己冲突的，一个事务里连续获取两个有冲突的锁类型是没有问题的。

### **表级锁**

#### 先用一张图总结一下八种锁的冲突关系

![CENTER_PostgreSQL_Community]( /images/news/2020/20200708_1444_图片1--2020.7_.8_.png)

#### 下面分别介绍一下这八种锁的场景：

#### 1.AccessShare
#### 在某个表上发出SELECT命令只读取表而不去修改它的查询都会获取该锁类型。
#### 冲突级别：8

#### 2.RowShare
#### SELECT FOR UPDATE/FOR SHARE命令会在目标表上取得一个这种模式的锁。
#### 冲突级别：7,8

#### 3.RowExclusive
#### 在表上发出UPDATE、DELETE和INSERT要修改表中数据时会取得这种锁模式。
#### 冲突级别：5,6,7,8

#### 4.ShareUpdateExclusive
#### 一些在线维护类操作所获得的锁，例如VACUUM（不带FULL）、ANALYZE、CREATE INDEX CONCURRENTLY、CREATE STATISTICS、ALTER TABLE VALIDATE等，该锁类型是自排他的。
#### 冲突级别：4,5,6,7,8

#### 5.Share
#### 发出CREATE INDEX命令（不带CONCURRENTLY）取得该锁，注意该锁不是自排他的。
#### 冲突级别：3,4,6,7,8

#### 6.ShareRowExclusive
#### 在以前老版本的官方文档中该锁不能通过发出某条数据库命令获得，而11以后的版本介绍该锁由CREATE COLLATION、CREATE TRIGGER和某些 ALTER TABLE命令获得。
#### 冲突级别：3,4,5,6,7,8

#### 7.Exclusive
#### 这种锁模式只允许并发的AccessShare锁，持有该锁只允许该表的只读操作。在以前老版本的官方文档中该锁不能通过发出某条数据库命令获得，而11以后的版本介绍该锁由REFRESH MATERIALIZED VIEW CONCURRENTLY获得。
#### 冲突级别：2,3,4,5,6,7,8

#### 8.AccessExclusive
#### 最高级别的锁，与所有模式的锁冲突，该锁保证持有者是访问该表的唯一事务。由DROP TABLE、TRUNCATE、REINDEX、CLUSTER、VACUUM FULL和REFRESH MATERIALIZED VIEW（不带CONCURRENTLY）命令获取。ALTER TABLE的某些命令也在会获得这种锁。同时，显式发出LOCK TABLE命令的默认锁模式也是该八级锁。
#### 冲突级别：所有

#### 值得注意的是savepoint之后获得的锁，在回退到保存点之前后该锁也会被事务释放。

### **实验**

#### 下面做几个小实验验证一下锁冲突。

#### 1.加列和查询冲突
#### 会话1：
```
postgres=# begin ;
BEGIN
postgres=# select * from test;
 id
----
  1
(1 rows)
```
#### 会话2：
```
postgres=# begin;
BEGIN
postgres=# alter table test add column a int;
```

#### 查询锁状态：
```
postgres=# select l.locktype,l.relation,l.pid,l.mode,l.granted,p.query_start,p.query,p.state from pg_locks l,pg_stat_activity p where l.locktype='relation' and l.pid=p.pid and query not like '%pg_stat_activity%';        
 locktype | relation |  pid   |        mode         | granted |          query_start          |               query                |        state        
----------+----------+--------+---------------------+---------+-------------------------------+------------------------------------+---------------------
 relation |    16782 | 500821 | AccessShareLock     | t       | 2020-06-20 09:42:21.338529+08 | select * from test;                | idle in transaction
 relation |    16782 | 502255 | AccessExclusiveLock | f       | 2020-06-20 09:43:08.922259+08 | alter table test add column a int; | active
(2 rows)
```

#### 2.读写互不阻塞
#### 会话1：
```
postgres=# begin;
BEGIN
postgres=# update test set id=2;
UPDATE 1
会话2：
postgres=# select * from test;
 id
----
  1
(1 row)
```

#### 查询锁状态：
```
postgres=# select l.locktype,l.relation,l.pid,l.mode,l.granted,p.query_start,p.query,p.state from pg_locks l,pg_stat_activity p where l.locktype='relation' and l.pid=p.pid and query not like '%pg_stat_activity%';
 locktype | relation |  pid   |       mode       | granted |          query_start          |         query         |        state        
----------+----------+--------+------------------+---------+-------------------------------+-----------------------+---------------------
 relation |    16782 | 429476 | RowExclusiveLock | t       | 2020-06-20 12:35:15.523242+08 | update test set id=2; | idle in transaction
 relation |    16782 | 429965 | AccessShareLock  | t       | 2020-06-20 12:35:26.266669+08 | select * from test;   | idle in transaction
(2 rows)
```

#### 3.在线创建索引
```
会话1：
postgres=# begin;
BEGIN
postgres=# select * from test;
 id
----
  1
(1 row)
```
#### 会话2：
```
postgres=# create index concurrently on test(id);
CREATE INDEX
```
#### 发现直接创建成功了，锁等待视图里面也没有相关信息。

#### 会话1：
```
postgres=# begin;
BEGIN
postgres=# update test set id=2;
UPDATE 1
```
#### 会话2：
```
postgres=# create index concurrently on test(id);
```

#### 发现hang了，查看锁视图：
```
postgres=# select l.locktype,l.relation,l.pid,l.mode,l.granted,p.query_start,p.query,p.state from pg_locks l,pg_stat_activity p where l.locktype='relation' and l.pid=p.pid and query not like '%pg_stat_activity%';
 locktype | relation |  pid   |           mode           | granted |          query_start          |                 query                  |        state        
----------+----------+--------+--------------------------+---------+-------------------------------+----------------------------------------+---------------------
 relation |    16782 | 156109 | ShareUpdateExclusiveLock | t       | 2020-06-20 13:33:36.050598+08 | create index concurrently on test(id); | active
 relation |    16782 | 158346 | RowExclusiveLock         | t       | 2020-06-20 13:33:31.494708+08 | update test set id=2;                  | idle in transaction
(2 rows)
```

#### 这里其实原因我上一篇文章专门介绍过，是因为先开启的会话1，造成长事务，引起会话2的创建索引事务等待。如果在一个大表上先直接并发创建索引，再update该表，基本是不会阻塞的（可能阻塞的原因是在创建索引的第二阶段获取快照之前有长事务未结束）。

#### 4.两个字段同时创建索引
#### 会话1：
```
postgres=# begin;
BEGIN
postgres=# create index on test(id);
CREATE INDEX
```
#### 会话2：
```
postgres=# begin;
BEGIN
postgres=# create index on test(a);
CREATE INDEX
```

#### 查询锁状态：
```
postgres=# select l.locktype,l.relation,l.pid,l.mode,l.granted,p.query_start,p.query,p.state from pg_locks l,pg_stat_activity p where l.locktype='relation' and l.pid=p.pid and query not like '%pg_stat_activity%' and l.relation=16782;
 locktype | relation |  pid   |   mode    | granted |          query_start          |           query           |        state        
----------+----------+--------+-----------+---------+-------------------------------+---------------------------+---------------------
 relation |    16782 | 156109 | ShareLock | t       | 2020-06-20 13:43:10.719273+08 | create index on test(a);  | idle in transaction
 relation |    16782 | 158346 | ShareLock | t       | 2020-06-20 13:42:35.576189+08 | create index on test(id); | idle in transaction
(2 rows)
```

#### 5.在线维护类操作自排他
#### 会话1：
```
postgres=# begin;
BEGIN
postgres=# analyze test;
ANALYZE
```
#### 会话2：
```
postgres=# create index concurrently on test(id);
```

#### 查询锁状态：
```
postgres=# select l.locktype,l.relation,l.pid,l.mode,l.granted,p.query_start,p.query,p.state from pg_locks l,pg_stat_activity p where l.locktype='relation' and l.pid=p.pid and query not like '%pg_stat_activity%' and l.relation=16782;
 locktype | relation |  pid   |           mode           | granted |          query_start          |                 query                  |        state        
----------+----------+--------+--------------------------+---------+-------------------------------+----------------------------------------+---------------------
 relation |    16782 | 156109 | ShareUpdateExclusiveLock | f       | 2020-06-20 13:56:21.525695+08 | create index concurrently on test(id); | active
 relation |    16782 | 158346 | ShareUpdateExclusiveLock | t       | 2020-06-20 13:55:24.686202+08 | analyze test;                          | idle in transaction
(2 rows)
```

![CENTER_PostgreSQL_Community]( /images/news/2020/20200708_1454_图片2--2020.7_.8_.png)

![CENTER_PostgreSQL_Community](/images/news/2016/pg_bot_banner.jpg)

评论:18501　　

顶: 23921　

踩: 22622　

请在登录后发表评论，否则无法保存。

18341# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 18:19:07+08

http://www.china-bbs.com/post/26804.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/14650.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/20639.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24179.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/23390.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/23211.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25857.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/27029.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/22671.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21098.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/20824.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9248.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/13603.html http://www.china-bbs.com/author-338.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24296.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/20409.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/26819.html

18342# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 18:17:19+08

http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11723.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/20752.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9570.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/22330.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/26761.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/26506.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11949.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24827.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/26684.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11684.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/16906.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/27268.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24281.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9144.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/13490.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/17365.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21404.html

18343# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 18:15:30+08

http://www.china-bbs.com/post/26226.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/23187.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24559.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11688.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/26469.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/17996.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/27869.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/26718.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/23864.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/25277.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9032.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/22197.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11968.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/10903.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/8649.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/23104.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/17788.html

18344# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 18:13:40+08

https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/20289.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/20414.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/15595.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/16826.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/18098.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/26677.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/16043.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25889.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9284.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/25989.html http://www.china-bbs.com/author-219.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/20375.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11227.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/28097.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/17982.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21428.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/16111.html

18345# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 18:11:52+08

http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/17488.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29446.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/18037.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11813.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25895.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/17223.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/23757.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/18370.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/26629.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24025.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/17899.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25709.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/13784.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/12899.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/28862.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/17321.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11858.html

18346# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 18:10:02+08

https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/23078.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/26522.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/14218.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/23963.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24238.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24545.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/26367.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21154.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/13454.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24133.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/25102.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/20409.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/15917.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/23050.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11291.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29753.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/10027.html

18347# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 18:08:12+08

http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/14619.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24614.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/23322.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/25848.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/22522.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/12120.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/21214.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21803.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24847.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/21619.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25434.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/15755.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/20881.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29416.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24837.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/17745.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/12913.html

18348# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 18:06:20+08

http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21415.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/26393.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/18555.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/21157.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/13800.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21766.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/26857.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/22703.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24802.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/28488.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/16284.html http://www.china-bbs.com/author-170.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/25527.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/23206.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/26690.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29739.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/8865.html

18349# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 18:04:31+08

http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/18032.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/23077.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/20175.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/25086.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/25802.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/25825.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/25762.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9730.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29051.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21587.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/18034.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/28024.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/25425.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25607.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24617.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21007.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/10345.html

18350# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 18:02:42+08

https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29466.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24935.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/26158.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24099.html http://qh.ahtcbmw.cn http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21846.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/10204.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11546.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/20449.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21345.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24604.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29322.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/12680.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/20386.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21181.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/author-580.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/23141.html

18351# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 18:00:50+08

http://www.china-bbs.com/post/20512.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/18541.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/28696.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/23133.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24181.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9738.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/17481.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/28219.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/21089.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21465.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/21268.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24530.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9505.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/19828.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/22010.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21403.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/14381.html

18352# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 17:58:59+08

http://www.china-bbs.com/post/22349.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/18177.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/20588.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/22489.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24480.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11566.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/27562.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21054.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24788.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/22053.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25765.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/25327.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/23620.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25290.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/18099.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/22700.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/27492.html

18353# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 17:57:10+08

http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24407.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/19803.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/10411.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24687.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/22945.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11634.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29976.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/8861.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/19979.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/23518.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29832.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/10979.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/17579.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25163.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/25506.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/26780.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29200.html

18354# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 17:55:10+08

http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21669.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24560.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29187.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/27374.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24202.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24180.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/27403.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25321.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/16696.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/17942.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29658.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/10906.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9700.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/10384.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21848.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11189.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/8839.html

18355# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 17:53:08+08

http://www.china-bbs.com/post/22989.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/27937.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/21677.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/20393.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/23924.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/12222.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9147.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/20794.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/21757.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/27122.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/23485.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/19122.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11926.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/8788.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/17939.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/15819.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/22371.html

18356# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 17:51:08+08

http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/15309.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/22475.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9019.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29270.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/16180.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/18614.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/27396.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/23397.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/21146.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29584.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/28457.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24068.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/13198.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/19795.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/20918.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/20834.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/22555.html

18357# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 17:49:08+08

http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/14635.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21831.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/26412.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9711.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/18088.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/25356.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/22874.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/22361.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/23897.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25327.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24875.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/26824.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/22773.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/author-757.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/22702.html http://www.china-bbs.com/author-180.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25057.html

18358# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 17:47:09+08

http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/10678.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/14973.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/20511.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/15587.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/16135.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/16746.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/19387.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/23811.html http://zhaohang.hftcbmw.cn http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/17847.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/10448.html http://www.china-bbs.com/?reg http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/14172.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25380.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9640.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25464.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24914.html

18359# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 17:45:12+08

http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/18305.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/18202.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/24234.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/26595.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/17006.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/13134.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/10737.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/23640.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/19436.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11119.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/20492.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/20445.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/28215.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/17196.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/24770.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/21528.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29286.html

18360# __ xcvxcvsdf 回答于 2024-07-28 17:43:16+08

http://www.china-bbs.com/post/22445.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/author-813.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11271.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/26146.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/26184.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/23908.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29965.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/21300.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/11588.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/17250.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/17945.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/9407.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/25222.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/20227.html http://www.china-bbs.com/post/27080.html http://zulin.china-bbs.com/post/18402.html https://bbs.tiancebbs.cn/post/29635.html